Battlestar Galactica: The Plan Blu-ray delivers great video and superb audio in this excellent Blu-ray release
Deep in the universe, cybernetic Cylons have all but wiped out the human race, laying waste to the Twelve Colonies of Man. Cast out, the few survivors aboard the Battlestar Galactica search for a so-called 13th colony: the mythical planet Earth.
I am, without a doubt, a tried and true Battlestar Galactica addict and apologist. But I'm also quick to admit that series creator Ron Moore and his talented writers failed to tie up a few loose ends ("plot holes" to the cantankerous critics among you) in the four-season arc of their acclaimed, genre-defying television masterpiece. Personally, I viewed each of these unsolved mysteries as collateral damage in one of the most inventive, unpredictable series I've ever had the pleasure of watching, but I know there are those out there who need to know every last detail. To that end comes The Plan, an unexpectedly subtle powerhouse that focuses on the Cylons and their efforts to eradicate humanity. Integrating scenes from the miniseries and the first two seasons, writer Jane Espenson and director Edward James Olmos systematically eliminate a variety of plot holes, weave an engrossing tale of love and loss, and provide a fresh perspective on BSG's devious skinjobs. Is it the jaw-dropper Olmos and company have been promising since the series finale? A redefining stunner sure to send fans scrambling back through all four seasons of the show? Not quite. It's simply another strong story in a long line of strong stories that have allowed Battlestar Galactica to emerge as one of the finest television series of the still-young 21st century.
How is this show not still on the air? I cry shenanigans...
After attempting to write three plot synopses for The Plan, I've come to a single conclusion: it's impossible to discuss even the most basic aspects of its story without revealing a slew of secrets from the series proper (in other words, don't go anywhere near this one unless you've watched all four seasons of the show). Suffice to say, the film explores the twisted tale of the first humanoid model Cylon, John Cavil (Dean Stockwell), and the reasons he and his brethren decided to eliminate the human race. Though almost every major BSG character makes an appearance to some degree -- Mary McDonnell's President Roslin is the lone exception, but her absence, while strange, is ultimately inconsequential -- this is, from the first attack on the Colonies to the final philosophical debate between a pair of Ones, Stockwell's film through and through. Likewise, while Baltar and his flesh-n-blood lot pop up from time to time (mainly in clips culled from the series' first two seasons), the other humanoid Cylons are The Plan's key secondary players. The focus on the machines is a welcome move that accomplishes a lot in very little time. The whereabouts of the Final Five is justified, the reason they're in the dark is revealed, Boomer's (Grace Park) sleeper state is explored, and the root of the human/Cylon conflict is dissected to near-Shakespearean, dare I say, Biblical lengths.
Cavil is presented as a Machiavellian mastermind; a Lucifer-like creation whose ascension to, and challenge of, the gods (or God, as Tricia Helfer's Six would emphatically declare) is as maniacal as it is tragic. His manipulation of everyone and everything in his path leaves him as lonely among his own kind as his parent model Cylons first made him feel. He doesn't realize how readily he perpetuates his own misery, nor does he seem to understand the irony of his circumstances, but his flaws make him all the more human; a characteristic the heartless skinjob would deny without hesitation. But it's precisely this sort of duality that makes him such a fascinating antagonist, so much so that Moore and Espenson's decision to place him at the forefront of the mythos is shown to be a brilliant move. He's both superior and inferior to his creators, a tantruming child with countless nuclear weapons in one hand and the entirety of the human and Cylon races in the other. His hatred of humanity seems to assure mutual destruction; his call to genocide is as insane as it is logical. To his credit, Stockwell turns in a startling performance that allows Olmos and Espenson to effortlessly pull back the proverbial curtain. His carefully mapped portrayal of two Cavils -- one on Galactica, one on Caprica with Anders (Michael Trucco) -- even gives the actor and the filmmakers the opportunity to examine the conflict in Cavil's own mind. Simply put, Stockwell makes The Plan the enthralling character study it is. His supporting castmates are just as strong (especially Rick Worthy, who didn't have anywhere near this much meaty material in the series), but Stockwell carries the brunt of the film's burdens with style.
Unfortunately, The Plan isn't the be-all, end-all series capper fans have been waiting for. There aren't any groundbreaking revelations (at least none that blew my fragile little mind), the seventh Cylon model still doesn't get his due (or, for that matter, any serious mention), the supernatural elements of the series have all but been abandoned in the film, and there are a number of lingering mysteries that weren't addressed in the slightest (which, for obvious reasons, I can't list here). I know Olmos and his team treated the film as Battlestar's last hurrah, but this post-series experiment will hopefully open the door for more projects that posthumously dig into other aspects of the show. I'd love to see Moore go back even further, to the moment Cavil's jealousy of Daniel first became evident; to investigate the backstories of more characters, to unspool the mysteries of more machinations, to peel back the layers of more storylines. That being said, The Plan is a welcome addition to the Battlestar canon that injects another batch of stirring stories into the mix at large. With potent performances, a simmering script, and an astonishing overview of the destruction of the Twelve Colonies (presented in a startling sequence sure to grace many a fan's Top Ten Battlestar Moments list) makes this flick well worth the price of admission. The fact that the Blu-ray edition offers a 111-minute Extended Cut only makes its home video release more enticing.
"The Blu-ray release of Battlestar Galactica: The Plan accurately preserves the artistic intentions of the creators. The stylized visual elements within certain scenes are intentional and faithful to the broadcast presentation of the television show."
With those wise words of warning, Universal introduces The Plan's 1080p/VC-1 transfer; an entirely faithful presentation of a wholly inconsistent visual experience BSG fans will find to be comparable to the series' previously released seasons. Girtty, grainy, and garish throughout, the film is a hodgepodge of palettes, lighting schemes, filters, and over/under-saturated hues that somehow, by the grace of Ron Moore, actually enhance the tone and mood of everything the Galactica crew and their Cylon nemeses face. Skintones remain relatively accurate (despite some gaudy flushing on the surface of Caprica), the vast reaches of space are deep and absorbing, and detail, while erratic at times, is quite stunning, particularly during close-ups. The melding of old series clips with new film footage is impressive as well. The only problem I noticed was with an early shot between Six and Cavil that was both blurry and riddled with noise. Granted, it passes by in an instant -- and is subsequently forgotten the moment the Cylon Basestars unleash hell on the Colonies using some of the series' finest CG to date -- but it stuck out in my mind as the lone hiccup in an otherwise strong presentation. It helps that Universal's technical transfer is so sound. Yes, minor banding is present in a few shots, but I didn't catch sight of any errant artifacting, unintentional noise or crush, edge enhancement, or DNR.
As it stands, anyone familiar with the Blu-ray edition of The Complete Series will know exactly what to expect from The Plan's high definition transfer. It isn't striking by traditional standards, but it does boast a strange, serrated beauty Battlestar enthusiasts have come to know and love.
Universal continues to demonstrate its affection for Battlestar Galactica with yet another powerful and proficient DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track. From the Cylons' devastating nuclear attacks on the Colonies to Anders' firefights on Caprica to the pulse-pounding bass that undergirds composer Bear McCreary's score, The Plan sounds absolutely fantastic. Slight normalization inconsistencies aside (an issue that's only noticeable when Olmos weaves scenes from the miniseries into the film), dialogue is both crisp and warm, prioritization is spot on, dynamics are bold and boisterous, and LFE output is a rumbling, roaring treat. The rear speakers are often restrained, but it only makes early club scenes, rapidly approaching action sequences, and the the film's most hair-raising set pieces that much more involving. Pans are Raptor smooth, directionality is precise, and the soundfield, from beginning to end, is as immersive as they come. If your fingers aren't drumming against your leg with McCreary's mesmerizing music, if chills aren't running across your scalp when the Basestars lay waste to the Colonies, if you aren't thoroughly pleased with Universal's efforts every time an explosion rocks the Galactica or an airlock hisses open, your heart is a dark pit from whence nothing returns.
The Plan may not boast the sort of jaw-dropping supplemental package Universal granted The Complete Series box set, but it still offers a thoroughly satisfying one. While I do wish some of the behind-the-scenes featurettes were longer, most fans will be too pleased with the content itself (and its high definition presentation) to complain too much.
Audio Commentary: Director Edward James Olmos sits down with writer/executive producer Jane Espenson for a soft-spoken, low-key discussion about the series, its characters, and the challenges Olmos and company faced in creating a cohesive film that revisited the first two seasons of Battlestar Galactica. Both speakers are incredibly humble and, while they tend to spend the first half hour complimenting everyone involved, manage to comment on everything of note, from the integration of new footage with old to the development of the script to the enthusiasm of the returning cast members. By the end of the commentary, I was ecstatic. Olmos and Espenson had not only provided all the information I could possibly want, they had effectively dissected the Cylons, the film's storylines, and the various questions and mysteries that were laid to rest throughout The Plan (some of which I didn't even realize were being addressed when I first watched the film). The only downside? Gaps of silence abound, especially from Olmos.
From Admiral to Director (HD, 7 minutes): An all-too-short featurette that looks at actor Edward James Olmos' approach to directing, his chemistry with the cast and crew, and the authority he brought to the filming of The Plan. Listening to him address a group of extras, explaining how integral each one is whether they have lines or not, is just one of many stirring moments that show why Olmos is one of Battlestar's finest directors.
Deleted Scenes (SD, 14 minutes): While many of the cuts included in this collection were wisely left behind, a few -- particularly a lengthy scene in which Cavil tries to manipulate an entire group of Caprican survivors -- would have worked well within the final film.
The Cylons of The Plan (HD, 7 minutes): Yet another woefully truncated featurette that nevertheless offers insightful interviews, intriguing analysis of Cavil and his at-times unwitting cohorts, candid behind-the-scenes footage, and details about the structure and significance of The Plan.
The Magic Behind The Plan (HD, 19 minutes): This suitably meaty FX documentary digs into the genesis of The Plan's effects shots, the use of CG, the team's pre-visualizations, and the point-A to point-Z development of some of the film's most astonishing scenes.
The Cylon Attack (HD, 4 minutes): A brief overview of an action scene involving Anders and an attack on a Clanker repair facility.
The Plan, while quite different than what I was expecting, is a thematically thrilling addendum to the Battlestar Galactica mythos that's sure to please diehards searching for every last BSG morsel to devour. Olmos remains one of the series finest directors, pulls powerful performances from his cast, and helms a sharply written, well-conceived script that plugs up plot holes and offers a semi-fresh look at the Cylons and their self-appointed leader, Cavil. Universal's Blu-ray release is just as strong with a faithful video transfer (that's comparable to The Complete Series' high definition presentation), a stirring DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, and a solid helping of special features. Battlestar junkies won't be disappointed.
Blu-ray bundles with Battlestar Galactica: The Plan (2 bundles)
For today only (June 8th, 2011), save 62% on Universal's "Battlestar Galactica: The Complete Series" Blu-ray collection at Amazon. This 21-disc box set, which includes both the miniseries that kicked off the series in 2004 and the unrated & extended version of ...
This Tuesday, Amazon is featuring a very interesting Blu-ray title for its Deal of the Day, just in case you had any money left from Black Friday. Today only, you can buy Battlestar Galactica: The Complete Series for just $119.99 (60% off MSRP). The price tracker ...
Starting today and for one week, Amazon.com is offering Battlestar Galactica: The Complete Series for only $132.99 (56% off MSRP). The price history feature for this title shows that this is the cheapest it has been since release. Note that this slimmer set also ...
» Show more related news posts for Battlestar Galactica: The Plan Blu-ray
Battlestar Galactica: The Plan Blu-ray, Forum Discussions
