Planet Earth Blu-ray offers solid video and decent audio in this enjoyable Blu-ray release
This Discovery Channel version is narrated by SIGOURNEY WEAVER. With an unprecedented production budget of $25 million, and from the makers of
Blue Planet:
Seas of Life, comes the epic story of life on Earth. Five years in production, over
2,000 days in
the field, using 40 cameramen filming across 200 locations, shot entirely in high
definition, this
is the ultimate portrait of our planet. A stunning television experience that captures
rare action,
impossible locations and intimate moments with our planet's best-loved, wildest and
most
elusive creatures. From the highest mountains to the deepest rivers, this
blockbuster series
takes you on an unforgettable journey through the daily struggle for survival in
Earth's most
extreme habitats. Planet Earth takes you to places you have never seen before, to
experience
sights and sounds you may never experience anywhere else.
Filmed entirely in high definition, shot in jaw-dropping locales over the course of several years,
and tossing out some of the most gorgeous, astonishing sequences you'll ever see as if they were
nothing more than Tootsie Roll candies at a parade, Planet Earth isn't just another
documentary series, it's a force of cinematic nature that, in this humble reviewer's opinion, has no
equal. However, shortly after plowing through its exceptional BBC Video release, I found myself
wondering if the US edition (produced and distributed directly by Discovery HD) was much different
from the British version. The answer, unfortunately, is yes... quite different. Not only does
Sigourney Weaver step in for narrator David Attenborough, five to seven minutes of footage has
been trimmed from each episode (dropping the series' total runtime by nearly seventy minutes),
the opening sequence has been changed, and the technical video presentation takes a slight hit in
quality. While the series itself is still quite powerful in the grand scheme of things, anyone seriously
considering Planet Earth should stick to the BBC Video version.
Please note: the specific screenshots in this review were taken in an attempt to highlight the
seemingly minor differences between the Discovery HD and BBC Video transfers.
With that bit of bad news out of the way, allow me to move on to the series proper.
Planet Earth doesn't waste any time establishing its purpose and intent with its first
episode, From Pole to Pole, an at-times unnerving introduction to our world's changing
climate, diverse wildlife, and shifting landscapes. First acquainting viewers with Antarctica and its
penguins, the BBC cameras move on to Canada, Russia, and Africa, stopping to watch predators
capture prey, herds adapt to their harsh surroundings, and migration patterns emerge.
Mountains explores the breathtaking mountain formations scattered across the globe
using stunning aerial photography, even taking time to examine the co-dependent behavior of
several species, the birth of new life, and endangered animals struggling to survive. Fresh
Water rushes alongside the rivers and inland streams of the world, all while investigating the
many creatures who depend on three percent of the planet's water supply to thrive. Salmon,
grizzlies, river dolphins, salamanders, piranha, and birds of all shapes and sizes are investigated at
length as Weaver dryly dissects the careful equilibrium each species strikes within its natural
habitat.
It only gets more interesting from there. Caves drops below the planet's surface,
plummeting down endless chasms, focusing on beasts who live their lives in darkness, and
revealing the extents to which species will adapt to their surroundings. Deserts travels to
Mongolia, Egypt, Australia, and more in search of life and death in the hottest, driest places on
Earth. At the opposite end of the spectrum is Ice Worlds, an intriguing episode that digs
into Antarctica, the Arctic, and the unique geological and ecological conditions of each pole region.
Great Plains turns the series' attention to the world's grasslands and their abundant
animal kingdoms. Jungles plunges into rainforests and, you guessed it, jungles to
uncover the strange and otherworldly creatures that inhabit the trees, brush, and waters of the
overgrown terrain. As the series begins to draw to a close, Shallow Seas turns its focus to
the aquatic mammals of the deep, numerous aquatic species, and a bizarre lineup of coral,
sharks, and squid. Seasonal Forests finds the PE crew examining the tallest trees in the
world, broad-leafed forests, more astonishing wildlife, and the changes brought on by the passing
seasons. Finally, Ocean Deep drops below the deepest waters of the planet to a place so
foreign that its strange creatures become the stuff of nightmares.
At every shot, stop, and subject, Planet Earth delivers some of the most mind-
blowing, heart-stopping, assumption-erasing visuals I've ever had the pleasure to watch. It's not
all soft and cuddly either -- death lurks around every corner, animals are shown as they are (not
as we want them to be), and genuine sadness is evoked on more than one occasion. At the same
time, the series captures a sense of unbridled wonder and limitless awe and the scope and sheer
enormity of our planet. I've never felt so privileged to feel so small and insignificant; I've never
felt so overwhelmed by a collection of fleeting images. Perhaps its the under-nurtured nature nut
in me, but I couldn't help but soak up every frame, every scene, and every sequence as if it were
the last I would see.
I may be out of adjectives, but I always find myself recommending Planet Earth to
anyone who will take the time to settle in for the long haul. While it can be a bit much for
younger children, it's an excellent series for families, classrooms, and private viewings; one of
those rare productions that can be literally enjoyed on some level by everyone. Its eleven
episodes require a healthy investment of time, but I think anyone who makes the investment
will be more than happy with the results. Just be sure to nab the BBC Video version to get the
most bang for your high definition buck.
Unlike the 1080p BBC Video version, the domestic Discovery HD release of Planet
Earth presents each episode with a somewhat inferior 1080i/AVC-encoded transfer. It
competently renders every wisp of dust, splinter of ice, and patch of fur, but its overall polish and
proficiency is a bit lacking. Detail is sharp as well… just not as refined as its British counterpart.
Even so, edges are well-defined, shadow visibility is notable, and texture clarity is reliable.
Moreover, colors remain vivid and inviting, saturation is still spot on, shadows are deep and
convincing, and solid contrast leads to enviable depth and dimensionality. Sadly, the picture is
haunted by a variety of technical mishaps that rarely affect the BBC edition. Artifacting and
wavering appear in the darkest scenes, mild noise clutters a few high-contrast shots, and banding is
more prevalent in undersea sequences. The full-length release of Planet Earth remains one
of the go-to releases I pop in when I want to impress my friends and family with the impact of high
definition. It looks fantastic from beginning to end, outperforms the standard DVD version in every
way, and continues to lead the pack when it comes to documentaries available on the market. Alas,
this comparatively disappointing American release is little more than an imposter.
Regardless of the version you choose, Planet Earth's only major weakness is its limited
Dolby Digital 5.1 surround track. Weaver's narration comes through as clear as anyone could hope
for, but the episodes simply don't have the sort of aural allure I wanted to hear paired with the
stunning photography. Ambience is middling in all but the most bombastic sequences, LFE
thooms rarely resonate with show-stopping power, and volume leveling could use some
work. Yes, most of the soundscape elements are passable -- most are even likely to subtly draw you
into the series as a whole -- but I couldn't shake the feeling that it could all sound much better.
Ultimately, I have to shrug my shoulders and admit that a narrated documentary series of this
nature rises and falls with its video transfer... not its audio track. While the audiophile in me still
wishes my ears were as overwhelmed as my eyes, documentary fans and Planet Earth
regulars will be pleased with what they hear.
The only area in which the domestic Discovery HD edition bests the BBC Video release is in
terms of supplemental content. While the 4-disc British version doesn't include any special
features, the US release offers a brief-but-interesting quartet of solid behind-the-scenes featurettes
(40 minutes). Granted, it doesn't amount to much, but it's certainly better than nothing.
Suffice to say, the US Edition of Planet Earth isn't worth any consideration so long as
the BBC Video
version is alive and kicking. The domestic release lops seventy minutes off the total series
runtime, inexplicably changes narrators, and comes up comparatively short in terms of video
quality. While it does tack on a few blink-and-you'll-miss-em featurettes, it simply can't measure up
to its big British brother. Be sure to pick up the BBC Video version if you have any intention of
bringing Planet Earth home.
