Video
Codec: MPEG-4 AVC Resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 1.34:1
Original aspect ratio: 1.33:1
Audio
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
English: LPCM 2.0
English: Dolby Digital 2.0
English: Dolby Digital 2.0 Note: Different narrator voices...
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 English: LPCM 2.0 English: Dolby Digital 2.0 English: Dolby Digital 2.0(less) Note: Different narrator voices, see review for details.
The General Blu-ray delivers stunning video and great audio in this exceptional Blu-ray release
Johnnie loves two things: his train and the lovely Annabelle Lee. When the Civil War breaks out
he enlists as a soldier, but it is decided that he is too valuable as an engineer. Annabelle thinks
it is because he is a coward. When Union spies capture Johnnie with Annabelle on board,
Johnnie "The General" must recue both his loves.
He's called The Great Stone Face, because his is worthy of a seaward-gazing spot on Easter Island—
stoic, deadpan, a blank onto which we can project our own emotions. He played it straight, never
hamming for the camera, never breaking character to sell a gag, always moving deliberately, with a
knowing clumsiness that can only be described as graceful. And yet, in his own time, Buster Keaton
pratfell into the shadow of Charlie Chaplin, that other silent comic mastermind. It's arguable who
was the greatest—I'd hate to choose between Steamboat Bill Jr. and The Kid—but
recent critical revision has seemingly sided with Keaton. No mere slapstick artist, Buster Keaton was
a comedic genius with the agility of a ballerina and the timing of a metronome. As a director of his
own films, he crafted sequences of kinetic insanity—performing his own frequently dangerous
stunts—and ultimately influencing the physical comedy of everything from Looney Toons to
Jackie Chan. Perhaps his greatest film—and the one that temporarily ended his career—is The
General, a madcap train-bound chase that was a box-office bust upon it's 1927 release, but has
since gone on to be recognized as one of the greatest comedies of the silent era. Or any era, for that
matter.
Johnnie Gray, Engineer.
In 1862, a small group of Union soldiers snuck behind enemy lines and commandeered a
locomotive, driving it northbound and tearing up track, throwing switches, and severing telegraph
wires along the way. They were caught—and most of them hanged—but William Pittenger
survived to write a memoir, The Great Locomotive Chase. Some 64 years after the
incident, the book landed in the hands of Buster Keaton, who saw it as prime material for
comedy. Only, there's really nothing funny about a group of soldiers getting caught and killed. So,
Keaton flipped allegiances and decided to tell the story from the perspective of the southern
engineer whose train was stolen. The actual train—which was called The General—was
decommissioned but still in existence somewhere in Georgia, and Keaton initially secured it for
use in the film. However, when the Confederate Veterans of the South caught wind that the film
was going to be a comedy—gasp—their gad-dum consternations and complaints were
enough to send Keaton packing to the Pacific Northwest, where he found a few nearly identical
trains to use. Shooting then commenced on one of the most expensive films of the silent
era.
Keaton himself plays Johnnie Gray, an engineer with two loves: his engine and the willowy
Annabelle Lee (Marion Mack). When the war breaks out, Johnnie tries to enlist, but he's turned
down because he's more valuable to the South as an engine driver. Of course, no one bothers to
tell him this, and his dejection is comically painful when he starts comparing himself to the tall,
fit, newly enlisted soldiers leaving the recruiting office. This gives way to true sadness when
Annabelle calls him a coward and refuses to speak with him until he's dressed in uniform. A year
later, Johnnie is piloting The General when it gets hijacked by Union soldiers disguised as civilians.
Annabelle happens to be on the train and gets kidnapped. Johnnie gives chase—on foot, with a
handcar, on a wooden penny-farthing bicycle, and finally in another steam locomotive, The Texas.
Alone behind enemy lines, Johnnie abandons the train and accidentally infiltrates the Union
headquarters, where he rescues Annabelle. The next morning, they retake The General, the
northern soldiers pursue in The Texas, and the whole chase happens again in reverse. For the
film's climax, Keaton sends The Texas across a burning bridge, which collapses into the river
below right as the train is mid-way across. This was the single most expensive scene in silent
movie history—reputedly costing $42,000, an astronomical sum at the time. The locamotive
remained lodged in the river until it was dismantled for scrap during WWII.
There's a scene in The Darjeeling Limited, Wes Anderson's latter-day train classic, where
the passenger train gets lost in the desert. "How can a train be lost?" says Jack. "It's on rails."
While no locomotives get lost in The General—at least, not in that way—Buster Keaton
deals in the same kind of absurdities. Great comedians of the day were known for their "gags,"
and Keaton seemingly dreamed them up and executed them effortlessly. You would think two
trains chasing one another couldn't possibly be exciting or funny—they're both stuck on tracks—
but Keaton finds a comedic beat for every situation, from a mishap with an enormous cannon to
repeated dousings from the track-side water tank. One thing that's clear when watching the film
is
that there's no way it could be created today; the stunts are genuinely dangerous and I have
trouble believing any insurer would carry the risk. Watch as Keaton darts in front of a moving
train to remove a plank of wood from the tracks; the train catches up with him and he falls back
onto the cowcatcher, where he tosses the piece of wood into another track-lodged log, sending
both pieces catapulting out of the way. Any misstep would find Keaton being pulverized into
ground comedian beneath the train.
For all the danger and excitement, it's Keaton's droll and weary humanity that elevates The
General from a zany silent comedy to a truly timeless classic. My favorite scene is when
Johnnie and Annabelle have re-stolen The General and are trying to escape their Northern
pursuers. Annabelle wants to make herself useful, so she starts loading wood into the engine's
stove. One large chunk of wood has a hole in it, so Annabelle promptly throws it out of the cabin,
picking up a small sliver to toss into the fire instead. Seeing this, Johnnie hands her an even
smaller piece. When she throws that piece into the fire, he mock strangles her in
exasperation before planting a tiny kiss on her cheek. It's a moment that exemplifies both
Keaton's comic timing and the brilliantly understated tenderness that underscores the entire film.
Let me preface this section by just saying that watching The General on Blu-ray is an
absolute pleasure. As the first silent film to make the jump to high definition in the United States,
I'm sure a lot of people are looking toward The General as a litmus test for how well films
from the '20s will perform on Blu-ray. Of course, quality will inevitably vary due to print damage,
etc., but I can say that I was consistently impressed by the 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer of
The General that Kino International has delivered here, a transfer sourced from a 35mm
archive print of the original camera negative. I'll be frank; this is not a complete restorative
overhaul of the film—which would be a herculean undertaking. White flecks and other debris
frequently pepper the frame, wear 'n tear lines sometimes streak down the image, brightness
flickers, and you'll notice the occasional bout of telecine wobble. For a film of this vintage,
however, all of that is excusable, if not expected. And you'll hardly notice, because the film's
newfound level of clarity and presence is simply fantastic. The image is, in general, exceptionally
detailed and sharp, easily besting prior home video releases of the film. Just examine the scene in
the rain when Johnnie Gray is trying to remove the bear trap from Annabelle's ankle. You can
make out the smallest ruffles in her skirt and easily see the minutest divots in the mud beneath
their feet. Cinematographers Bert Haines and Deveraux Jennings routinely employ shallow depth
of field, which gives the picture a strong dimensionality evocative of Civil War-era photography.
Film historian David Robinson said it best when he wrote, "Every shot has the authenticity and
the unassuming correct composition of a Matthew Brady Civil War photograph." The film is given
a slight sepia toning here—except for the few night scenes, which have a bluish tint—and the
gradation between the darkest and lightest portions of the image is perfect. Contrast is strong but
rarely overblown, and blacks—which are really deep brown in sepia—are dark and substantial.
Finally, the film's grain structure is exceptionally fine. Once you look past the negligible print
damage, you'll have no qualms at all about The General's picture quality.
As with their previous DVD release of the film, Kino International has loaded this disc with a
multitude of audio options. The highlight is a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 score conducted by Carl
Davis, orchestrated by Nicholas Raine, and performed by the Thames Silents Orchestra for a BBC
presentation of The General in 1987. I have no idea what the film's original orchestration
was like—and I'm sure it varied from theater to theater—but if it was anything like this score, I'm
sure audiences would've been bowled over. The music is comprised of original themes mixed with
rearrangements of classic period tunes, including a fantastic minor-key reinterpretation of "Dixie."
All of the arrangements are perfectly timed with the film, even down to creating musical "sound
effects" for certain on-screen gags. The music is quite full, with the low, detailed timbre of cellos,
horns that pierce cleanly, and flutes and oboes taking off in lofty directions. There's also a 2.0
LPCM version of this score, which is just as strong. The disc also includes two additional scores,
both presented in Dolby Digital 2.0. Composer Robert Israel's score is derived from traditional
silent movie tunes, and prominently features piano and strings. For a lossy track, the music here
sounds excellent, but the music is not quite as memorable or engaging as the Carl Davis score.
Finally, we have Lee Irwin's organ score, which was recorded in Carnegie Hall and commissioned
during the 1970s to accompany theatrical reissues of The General. I really like this track
—it's haunting and effective in a way that only organ accompaniment can be. There's a bit of hiss
and crackle to the audio, but this only adds to the creaky, old-time vibe.
Video Tour of The General (1080p, 18:05)
Historian and locomotive expert Harper Harris recounts the true story on which The
General was based, gives us a tour of the actual engine, and explains how Keaton wanted to
use the authentic train for his film but was denied when Civil War veterans protested on the
grounds that The General was going to be comedy.
The Buster Express (1080i, 5:47)
Trains were featured prominently in several Buster Keaton silent films, and this five-minute
montage cobbles together several clips, all set to some jolly, old-timey organ music.
Tour of Filming Locations (1080i, 4:29)
John Bengston, author of Silent Echoes, points out locations used during the filming of
The General, allowing us to see what they look like some 80 years later.
Home Movie Footage (1080i, 1:00)
The filming of The General attracted scores of onlookers, some of whom filmed their own
home movies of visits to the sets.
Intro by Gloria Swanson (1080i, 2:13)
Silent film star Gloria Swanson (Queen Kelly) introduces the film in this segment that
was meant to accompany TV broadcasts of the film in the early 1960s.
Intro by Orson Welles (1080i, 12:21)
Filmed for for Paul Killiam's The Silent Years, a series of silent classics aired on public
television in 1971, this intro features the stately Orson Welles looking back fondly on his own
memories of Keaton and dissecting some of the actor's comic techniques.
Photo Gallery
This user-controlled gallery contains over 75 publicity stills, posters, and candid photos.
If you've never given silent films a chance, The General is an excellent place to start. It's
funny, tender, and so genuinely thrilling that you'll never miss dialogue, sound effects, or any of the
other cinematic accoutrements introduced with the advent of "talkies." Kino International has done
a
terrific job with this release—the film looks stunning—and for anyone interested in early comedy or
the films of the 1920s, I have no reservations in giving The General my highest
recommendations.
Blu-ray review site Doblu has interviewed DVD and Blu-ray producer Bret Wood on the preparation of Buster Keaton's 'The General' for its Blu-ray edition, which was released November 10. In the interview, Wood discusses in depth the specific challenges transferring ...
Kino Video is set to release Buster Keaton's silent-cinema masterpiece 'The General' on Blu-ray on November 10, making it the first silent feature film on BD in America (although the absolute record is for the UK release of 'Sunrise', which comes out September ...
