Best Blu-ray Deals

Best Blu-ray Deals, See All the Deals »
Top deals | Price drops  
 All countries United States United Kingdom Canada Germany France Spain Italy Japan
The Equalizer (Blu-ray)
Cowboy Bebop: The Complete Series (Blu-ray)
Archer: The Complete Season Five (Blu-ray)
American Sniper (Blu-ray)
The Expendables 3 (Blu-ray)
16 hrs ago
The Interview (Blu-ray)
The Lady From Shanghai (Blu-ray)
2015 Allstate Sugar Bowl (Blu-ray)
The Book of Life 3D (Blu-ray)
Big Hero 6 (Blu-ray)
The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (Blu-ray)
Sons of Anarchy: Season Seven (Blu-ray)
Manage your own movie collection and always keep it with you with our Apps. Price track movies and get price drop notifications instantly. Become a member to take full advantage of all site features.

Sony Settles Blu-ray Patent Dispute

Posted May 28, 2008 08:40 AM by Josh Dreuth

Blu-ray DiscSony has settled a lawsuit with Columbia University Professor Emerita Gertrude Neumark Rothschild which focused on the technology used for basic semiconductor technology used in current Blu-ray players. During the 80's and 90's, Professor Rothschild owns patents for wide band-gap semiconductors which are widely recognized to have led to the development of short-wavelength light emitting diodes, such as the blue laser diode used for Blu-ray.

Albert L. Jacobs, Jr. of Dreier LLP Intellectual Property commented, " Professor Rothschild is very pleased that both Sony and Sanyo, and other major electronics makers have recognized her major scientific contributions to LED and LD technology. Professor Rothschild made a seminal breakthrough in understanding the doping requirements necessary for the production of the blue, green, violet and ultraviolet LEDs and LDs on a commercial and efficient scale that are essential to today's consumer electronics, and highly deserves this recognition for her work."

Details of the settlement were not released.

Source: | Permalink | United States [Country settings]

News comments (9 comments)

  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
Hmm, shame on you Sony for doing that! Good to hear it was resolved without issue.

Top reviewer
Top contributor
  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
That is very cool that they looked after Professor Rothschild instead of letting her foot the bill for a lawsuit all the way to the highest courts.

People should be rewarded for their personal work that advances any technology or science.

Top contributor
Blu Titan
  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
Corporations infringe on patent protection all the time. A patent is worthless unless you have the financial means to defend it in court. Glad to see that Professor Rothschild did not get ripped off.

Robert Franklin
  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
It wasn't just Sony. It was other CE copanies as well, but I'm glad she deserves credit and credit is due her. She's gonna get PAID!!

  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
Way to make amends. If it were not for the research and development done by these fine people, technology would not advance. By Sony (and other CE's) recognizing those persons contributions keeps those types of people with the imaginative spirit interested in evolving technology. If they were bulldozed over by the large powers that be and not recognized for their work, they would have no reason to evolve current technology and invent others.

But one interesting note is the mention of Violet and Ultraviolet LEDs. Imagine the future possibilities for optical storage space with wavelengths in the 200-400nm range.

  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
Huh. I am sure Sony is not suffering from this at all.
I knew they would settle sooner or later.
  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
Hey, you guys got this all wrong. Here is how it works -- instead of doing a comprehensive patent search of anything and everything that your product may infringe upon, which is not possible, most companies only do a simple search. In a lot of the cases, the original patent is either very vague or very broad, which requires people with great scientific and technical knowledge to interpret. Even that, it may not be possible all the time. The court, and most patent lawyers, are certainly even less qualified to do so. So, the common practice for most corporations is to take a risk. They do a simple patent search. If they don't find anything, they can go ahead with the product development. The penalty on patent infringement is less severe if you don't know about the existence of the patent than if you do. If you know about the patent, and purposedly infringe upon it, the penalty is higher. That's why it is better if you don't do a lengthy search and attempt to interpret every patent that may remotely related to the product that you are trying to develop. If this is your approach, you will never succeed in bringing out new products. Because by the time you are done with the patent search, you will have missed the market already. Companies are betting on the fact that the patent holder doesn't come forth. This is usually the case. If and when s/he does, they will settle it outside of the court. It is far cheaper to do it this way. This is exactly what Sony and Sanyo did, which is indeed the right approach.

  May 28, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
well at least she got her comeupants

  May 29, 2008
Vote plusVote minus Report as inappropriate
I'm suprise she got something out of this, I thought this whole lawsuit from Rothschild was ridiculous... she tried to sue other companies in the past and failed, all were ridiculous claims... she could of brought this lawsuit the day HD-DVD/Blu-ray came out but she waited over a year then finally decided to sue the companies... geeeee I wonder why. She just wants to milk as much money as she can.

Oh well, glad this whole lawsuit deal got resolved.

Add comment

Please login to post a comment.


Get Daily Blu-ray Deals

* We do not share your email and you may opt out at any time.

Top Blu-ray Deals


The best Blu-ray deals online. Don't miss out on these great deals.

See Today's Deals »

 Top movies

Latest Deals United States

The latest deals on Blu-ray movies
at Amazon.

Show new deals »

Trending Blu-ray Movies
1. Lucy
2. Lucy
3. Gone Girl
4. The Grand Budapest Hotel
5. Fright Night
6. GoodFellas
7. Interstellar
8. Lucy
9. Annabelle
10. The Drop
11. The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
12. The Zero Theorem
13. Guardians of the Galaxy 3D
14. The Boxtrolls 3D
15. American Sniper

Trending in Theaters
1. American Sniper
2. Interstellar
3. Big Hero 6
4. The Imitation Game
5. The Interview
6. The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies
7. Taken 3
8. Inherent Vice
9. The Babadook
10. Into the Woods
11. Selma
12. Nightcrawler
13. Blackhat
14. The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1
15. Foxcatcher
16. Paddington
17. A Most Violent Year
18. The Theory of Everything
19. Horns
20. Predestination
21. The Gambler
22. The Wedding Ringer
23. Exodus: Gods and Kings
24. Horrible Bosses 2
25. Dumb and Dumber To
26. Jessabelle
27. Penguins of Madagascar
28. Unbroken
29. The Woman in Black 2: Angel of Death
30. Two Days, One Night
31. Big Eyes
32. Wolves
33. Wild
34. Annie
35. Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb
36. Top Five
37. Vice
38. Revenge of the Green Dragons
39. Rosewater
40. Before I Go to Sleep
41. Song of the Sea
42. Fugly!
43. [REC] 4: Apocalypse
44. Poker Night
45. The Homesman
46. Leviathan

Top 10 Sellers United States
1.  Big Hero 6
2.  Fury
3.  Game of Thrones: The Complete Fourt...
4.  Downton Abbey: Season 5
5.  The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1
6.  Lucy
7.  Interstellar
8.  Guardians of the Galaxy 3D
9.  The Equalizer
10.  American Sniper
  » See more top sellers

Top 10 Pre-orders United States
1.  Big Hero 6
2.  Fury
3.  Game of Thrones: The Complete Fourt...
4.  Downton Abbey: Season 5
5.  The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1
6.  Interstellar
7.  American Sniper
8.  The Book of Life
9.  John Wick
10.  The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five ...
  » See more pre-orders

Top 10 Bargains United States
1.  Big Hero 6
$18.90, Save 53%
2.  Game of Thrones: The Complete Fourt...
$39.96, Save 50%
3.  Downton Abbey: Season 5
$29.96, Save 46%
4.  The Equalizer
$14.99, Save 57%
5.  The Grand Budapest Hotel
$11.99, Save 70%
6.  The Book of Life
$19.99, Save 50%
7.  The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
$5.99, Save 85%
8.  The Expendables 3
$15.00, Save 62%
9.  The Princess Bride
$5.99, Save 70%
10.  Dredd 3D
$9.96, Save 60%
  » See more deals

Most Popular Blu-ray Movie Deals

The Equalizer

 United States

$34.99 $14.99

Cowboy Bebop: The Complete Series

 United States

$59.98 $34.49

Archer: The Complete Season Five

 United States

$39.99 $19.99

Best Blu-ray Movie Deals »

This web site is not affiliated with the Blu-ray Disc Association.
All trademarks are the property of the respective trademark owners.
© 2002-2015 All rights reserved.
Registration problems | Business/Advertising Inquiries | Privacy Policy | Legal Notices